In the ever-evolving landscape of social media, from TikTok to Twitter, a recent debate has captured the internet’s attention: women claiming they would rather be trapped with a bear than with a random man in the woods. This provocative sentiment has sparked a flurry of reactions, from humorous memes to serious discussions about gender dynamics. But what’s behind this surprising preference? Why would some women express a preference for a potentially dangerous animal over a human companion?
This extreme comparison sheds light on deeper issues within relationships with men. Many women feel disillusioned by their interactions, citing experiences of disrespect, lack of empathy, and emotional unavailability. The bear, in this context, symbolizes a break from these negative encounters and the appeal of solitude and the natural world.
Beyond the shared feelings of disappointment towards men, this debacle has sparked a poignant discussion about feelings of safety and trust among women and survivors of abuse. Many participants have shared their experiences of feeling unsafe around men due to past traumas, particularly incidents of sexual assault. Preferring a bear over a man, while seemingly illogical to some, reflects a deep-seated fear and mistrust rooted in these traumatic experiences.
Read more: Stop Blaming Mothers and Ignoring Government and Society’s Roles on Maternal Health
Therefore, it should be logical that many women and survivors express their preference for a bear over a man as a manifestation of their trauma-induced apprehension. This choice underscores the profound impact of past experiences on perceptions of safety and trust within communities. Conversely, some men argue against this choice. Citing its lack of logical sense as bears should be seen as something far more dangerous than a human being, because of its position as a natural predator.
However, bear attacks rarely happen. It is also mentioned by the US National Park Service that the chance of being attacked by a bear is just 1 in 2.7 million visits. As reported by Bombieri et al. (2019), the global bear attack rate averages about 39.6 attacks per year, with North America experiencing around 11.4 attacks annually and Europe seeing about 18.2 attacks per year (or 10 if excluding Romania). In the East, the reported 19 attacks per year are likely underestimated due to insufficient data from various regions.
Meanwhile, Indonesia is home to only two subspecies of sun bears (Helarctos malayanus), which is the world’s smallest bear species. These bears are mostly found in Sumatra and Kalimantan. Despite that, there are Indonesian women who gave their response in this debate when Indonesia is a country where bear attacks hardly occur. It is worthwhile to note that these attacks only occur when bears feel threatened as they are protecting their food or their cubs (Laybourne, 2023).
Read more: Continuously Dramas Lead Me to Find My Other Identity
This brings us to another question—does sexual assault occur more often than bear attacks? According to WHO estimates, approximately 30% of women globally have experienced physical and/or sexual violence from an intimate partner or non-partner at some point in their lives. The majority of this violence is perpetrated by intimate partners. Nearly one-third (27%) of women aged 15-49 who have been in a relationship report having faced physical and/or sexual violence from their intimate partner. The data provided is probably just the tip of the iceberg.
Based on the data presented, men are more likely to perpetuate harm to women compared to bears attacking people of any gender. Across cultures worldwide, attitudes toward gender are likely to affect how male-female relationships are viewed. Also, subsequently, how the sexual offenders and the victims are viewed.
In places where traditional masculine roles are highly valued, men may feel a greater sense of entitlement. If a woman resists sexual advances, it can be perceived as a challenge to their masculinity, potentially triggering an identity crisis (Kaltra & Bugra, 2013). This can lead to attempts at sexual control and violence as a means to reassert their perceived power and resolve this crisis. Despite this, there are many other factors at play that may lead to why men would sexually assault women, albeit verbally or physically.
Read more: Four Fundamental Critics of the Inadequate Implementation of Law on Sexual Violence Crimes
The internet debate where women express a preference for being alone with a bear over a man highlights profound issues within gender relations and societal attitudes towards safety and trust. This sentiment, while hyperbolic, reflects deep-seated frustrations with disrespect, lack of empathy, and emotional unavailability experienced in relationships with men. It underscores a broader discourse about the pervasive fear and mistrust stemming from past traumas, particularly sexual violence.
While bear attacks are statistically rare, the fear of interpersonal violence is an ever-present reality for many women. The stark contrast in the frequency of bear attacks versus incidents of sexual assault reveals a disturbing truth about the threats women face in their everyday lives. This comparison sheds light on the urgent need to address and mitigate the factors contributing to male violence against women. Including cultural attitudes that valorize traditional masculine roles and entitlements.
Ultimately, this conversation pushes us to reflect on the ways we can foster safer and more respectful relationships. By acknowledging the gravity of these issues and working towards systemic change, we can hope to create a world where women do not feel compelled to choose the solitude of the wilderness over the company of men. This dialogue is a crucial step towards achieving greater empathy, understanding, and ultimately, a more equitable society.
